Can Employees Review the Business They Work For?
Google treats a review from a current or former employee as a conflict of interest. See what staff may and may not do, and what to do instead.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 8 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
No. Google's policy treats a review from a current or former employee as a conflict of interest, and that covers positive and negative reviews alike. A review is meant to describe a customer's real experience of a business. Someone who is paid by that business, or used to be, is not an independent customer. The rule also covers owners reviewing their own business and anyone reviewing a competitor. This guide explains what the policy says, the cases owners ask about most, and the useful things staff can do in place of writing reviews.
What does Google's policy say?
Google's prohibited and restricted content policy covers reviews and other contributions on Google Maps. One part deals with conflict of interest. It says content should reflect a genuine experience, and it lists reviewing your own business, posting about a current or former employment experience, and posting about a competitor to manipulate its rating as conflicts of interest.
In plain terms:
- Owners may not review their own business.
- Current employees may not review the business they work for.
- Former employees may not use reviews to post about what it was like to work there.
- Nobody may review a competitor to drag down its rating.
The rule does not depend on the star rating. A glowing review from the receptionist breaks it just as much as a bitter one from someone who was dismissed.
Why does the rule exist?
Because readers assume a review comes from a customer. Someone choosing a dentist or a garage reads reviews to learn what happened to people like them. A review from a member of staff answers a different question, and the reader has no way of knowing that.
There is a practical side as well. Staff reviews are easy to spot. In a small town, customers recognize the name of the person who served them. A profile where three of the first ten reviews come from people who work there does more harm than a profile with seven honest ones.
What about an employee who is also a customer?
This is the most common question. The barista buys coffee there. The mechanic has their own car serviced at the shop. The stylist gets a haircut from a colleague.
The policy makes no exception for this. The person is still an employee, with a clear interest in how the business looks. The safe course is simple: staff do not review their own workplace, whether or not they also buy from it.
What about family and friends of the owner or staff?
The pages we cite name owners, employees and competitors. We will not claim more than they say about relatives and friends.
The principle behind the policy still gives a workable test: is this a real customer describing a real experience, with no pressure and no reward? A relative who has never used the business has nothing true to write. One who is a regular customer has a real experience, but readers who recognize the surname will discount the review, and so might you. A business is better served by reviews from customers with no ties at all.
Do not organize it. A message to the whole family saying "everyone leave us five stars tonight" is a request for reviews from people chosen because they will be kind. Google's policy says a business may not selectively solicit positive reviews.
Can a former employee leave a negative review?
It happens, usually after a difficult departure. The policy names former employees as well as current ones, so a review about what it was like to work at the business falls under the conflict of interest rule.
If you receive one:
- Do not reply in anger, and do not reveal anything about the person's employment.
- Report the review. Google's page on reporting inappropriate reviews explains that only reviews that violate its policies are eligible for removal, and conflict of interest is one of those policies.
- Post a short, neutral reply in the meantime. Google says an evaluation typically takes several days, and the review stays visible until then.
A suitable reply: "Thank you for your comment. We have no record of this as a customer visit. If we have missed something, please contact us directly."
Do not write "this person was fired for misconduct." It may be true. It is also a private employment matter, and it makes the business look worse than the review did. Our guide on how to report a Google review walks through the reporting steps.
One caution. A former employee who later comes in as an ordinary paying customer and describes that visit is a harder case. Report it if you believe it breaks the policy, and accept that Google makes the decision.
Can staff ask customers for reviews?
Yes, and this is where staff are most useful. Asking customers is allowed and encouraged. Google's tips for getting more reviews tell businesses to ask.
The line is between asking and writing:
- Allowed: a member of staff saying "If you have a minute, would you leave us a Google review?"
- Not allowed: a member of staff writing the review, on their own phone or the customer's.
- Not allowed: a member of staff taking the customer's phone and typing for them.
- Not allowed: a member of staff choosing only pleased customers to ask.
Our guide on how to ask for reviews in person has scripts staff can use.
Can you require staff to leave reviews?
No, and some owners do it without knowing the rule. "Everyone leave us a review before the end of the month" is an instruction to break Google's policy. It also puts staff in an unfair position, since the review appears under their own name and account.
The same goes for softer versions: a suggestion at a team meeting, a line in an onboarding checklist, or a manager who "would really appreciate it." If a review from staff is not allowed, a request for one is not appropriate either.
Can you reward staff for reviews?
You can reward staff for asking. Be careful about rewarding them for results.
- A bonus for each five-star review pushes staff to press customers, to ask for a rating, and to ask only the customers who look pleased. Each of those causes a problem of its own. Our article on whether it is OK to ask for a five-star review explains why.
- Recognition for asking is safer. Thank the person who makes the request most consistently.
Never pass a reward on to the customer. Google's help page on review links and QR codes says incentives in exchange for reviews are strictly prohibited.
If each card has its own link, as Smart Review Stand cards do, the dashboard counts taps per card. That shows who is asking, without counting stars.
What should you do if staff have already left reviews?
Fix it quietly.
- Check your reviews for familiar names. Include former staff, and your own account.
- Ask each person to delete their review. The writer of a review can remove it from their own Google account at any time.
- Explain the reason. Most staff who did this meant well and did not know the rule.
- Add one line to your staff guidance: "Please do not review the business on Google. Ask customers instead."
Do not leave them in place and hope. A review can be reported by anyone who notices it, including a competitor, and a profile cleaned up by its owner looks better than one cleaned up by Google.
What if a customer mentions an employee by name?
That is fine. A customer who writes "Luis explained everything clearly" is describing a real experience. Reviews that name staff are often the most persuasive ones on a profile.
What staff should not do is ask for it as a favor or a condition. "Mention my name so I get the bonus" turns an honest review into a transaction.
What can staff do that actually helps?
Plenty, and none of it involves writing a review.
- Ask every customer at the end of the visit, in one sentence.
- Point to the card or code so the customer can act in seconds.
- Step away while the customer writes.
- Listen when a customer says they were unhappy, and fix what can be fixed.
- Read the reviews. Sharing new ones at a weekly meeting shows the team what customers notice.
With Smart Review Stand, a customer taps the card or scans its code and sees a page with your logo and five stars. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it. No app is needed. The card is for customers only. Staff should test it, then close the page without posting. You can see what the service includes on the features page.
For the wider set of rules, see our guide to the Google review policy.
What is the short version?
- Current and former employees may not review the business they work for or worked for.
- The rule covers positive and negative reviews alike.
- Owners may not review their own business, and nobody may review a competitor to lower its rating.
- Staff may ask customers for reviews. They may not write them.
- Never require or pressure staff to leave a review.
- If staff reviews exist, ask the writers to delete them.
- Report a former employee's review, and post a neutral reply while Google considers it.