How to Follow Up a Review Request Without Nagging
One polite reminder a few days later is enough to follow up a review request. See when to send it, what to say, and when to stop asking.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 9 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
Follow up a review request once, three to seven days after the first ask, with a short message that includes the link and makes it plain that the review is optional. Then stop. Most customers who say "of course" and never post have simply forgotten, and one reminder is enough to catch them. This guide covers why customers forget, when to send a reminder, what to write, how to avoid nagging, and what to do with the customers who stay silent.
Why do customers agree and then not leave a review?
Because life gets in the way. A customer who meant it at the counter has a full inbox and a busy evening by the time they get home.
The usual reasons:
- They forgot. By far the most common.
- They could not find the link. A paper receipt went in the bin, or the email is buried.
- They were not signed in to Google. The form asked for a sign-in and they gave up.
- They did not know what to write. A blank box is harder than it looks.
- They were being polite. Some people say yes and mean no.
A reminder helps with the first four. Nothing helps with the fifth, and nothing should. Our guide on why customers don't leave reviews covers each reason in more depth.
Is it acceptable to follow up at all?
Yes, within limits. Google's tips for getting more reviews encourage businesses to ask customers for reviews and mention thank-you emails and receipts as places to do it. The pages we cite do not give a number of reminders, so we will not pretend they do. The limit of one reminder is our advice, not Google's.
What Google's prohibited and restricted content policy does say is this:
- No incentives. A reminder cannot carry a reward.
- No selective soliciting. A business may not ask only the customers it expects to be positive.
- No discouraging negative reviews.
So a reminder is fine when it goes to everyone you asked, offers nothing, and leaves the customer free to say whatever they think.
There may also be local rules about marketing messages by email and text. We are not lawyers. If you are unsure whether a reminder counts as marketing where you trade, check before you send.
When should you send the reminder?
Three to seven days after the first ask. Sooner feels impatient. Later, and the visit has faded.
Adjust for the kind of business:
- Cafes, shops and quick visits. Three days. The memory is short.
- Salons, dentists and appointments. Three to five days.
- Trades and home services. Five to seven days. The customer has had time to see that the repair holds.
- Long projects and big purchases. A week, or after the final check-in call.
Time of day matters less than people think. Early evening on a weekday is a reasonable default, because many people look at personal messages then. Avoid late at night and first thing on a Monday.
Our guide on the best time to ask for a Google review covers the timing of the first ask.
Which channel should you use?
The one you already use to talk to that customer. A reminder should arrive in a familiar place.
- Email. The safest default. Easy to ignore politely, easy to find later.
- A reply in an existing thread. If you and the customer have been emailing about a job, add a line to your next message.
- In person, on the next visit. For regulars, this is the best reminder of all.
- A printed card with the invoice. Useful for customers who do not use email much.
Smart Review Stand does not send text messages, and we suggest caution with texts in general. A text is more intrusive than an email, and many customers did not give their number for that purpose.
What should the reminder say?
Two or three sentences. Thanks, link, optional. Here are four versions.
After a first email went unanswered.
"Hi Dana, thank you again for coming in last week. If you still have a minute for a Google review, here is the link: [your link]. If not, no problem at all."
After an in-person yes.
"Hi Marcus, you kindly said you would leave us a review, so here is the link to make it easy: [your link]. Only if you still feel like it."
After a finished job.
"Hi Elena, I hope the new boiler is behaving. If you are happy with the work, an honest Google review would help us a great deal: [your link]. Either way, call me if anything needs attention."
To a regular, in person.
"Good to see you again, Ben. The review card is on the counter if you ever get a moment. No rush."
What each one has in common:
- It is short. The customer can read it in five seconds.
- The link is in the message. Nobody has to search for it.
- It says the review is optional.
- It asks for an honest review, not a good one.
Our Google review request email template guide has wording for the first ask.
What makes a reminder feel like nagging?
Repetition, guilt and pressure. Any one of them turns a courtesy into a chore.
Avoid these:
- A second and third reminder. One is the limit.
- "We noticed you have not left a review yet." It reads as surveillance.
- "It only takes 30 seconds." It tells the customer their reason is not good enough.
- "Reviews are vital to a small business like ours." Guilt.
- "Please leave us five stars." A request for a rating, not a review.
- A reminder with a reward attached. Against Google's policy.
- Reminders from several members of staff. The customer feels chased.
A simple test: would you be comfortable saying the reminder aloud to the customer's face? If it sounds needy or pushy when spoken, rewrite it.
How do you make the review easier the second time?
Remove the obstacles that stopped the customer the first time. A reminder that repeats the same difficult route will get the same result.
- Use a direct link. One that opens the review form, not your profile. Google's help page on review links and QR codes explains where to get it. Our free Google review link generator turns a Google Place ID into a write-a-review link and QR code.
- Give a prompt. "A line about what you had done is plenty." That solves the blank box.
- Keep the message free of clutter. No newsletter, no offers, no other links.
- Test the link on a phone. Send the reminder to yourself first.
Do not suggest wording for the review itself. A prompt about the topic is fine. A script is not.
How do you avoid reminding someone who already left a review?
Check before you send. A reminder to a customer who posted yesterday is embarrassing.
- Look at your recent reviews. Match names where you can.
- Keep a simple list. Date asked, date reminded, done.
- When in doubt, soften the wording. "If you have already left one, thank you, and please ignore this."
You will not always be able to match a review to a customer. Reviewer names on Google do not always match the name on your booking. The softened wording covers that case.
Should you send reminders only to happy customers?
No. Send the reminder to everyone who received the first request, or to no one.
Picking out the customers who seemed pleased is selective soliciting, and Google's policy does not allow it. It also gives you a rating you cannot trust. Our guide on what review gating is explains the rule.
There is one fair exception, and it is about kindness and not about ratings. If a customer has an open complaint with you, deal with the complaint. Do not send a cheerful review reminder into the middle of it.
What if the customer still does not respond?
Leave it. Silence is an answer.
What to do instead:
- Thank them the next time you see them, for their custom and not for a review.
- Keep the card on the counter. A customer who ignored two messages may tap a card six months later.
- Put your energy into asking the next customer well.
A steady habit of asking everyone once, with one reminder, will produce more reviews than chasing any individual. Our guide on how to get reviews from repeat customers covers the long game with regulars.
How do you keep track without a big system?
A notebook or a spreadsheet with four columns is enough for most small businesses.
- Name.
- Date of first ask.
- Date of reminder.
- Closed. Either a review appeared or the reminder went out. Nothing further happens.
Set one time a week to send reminders. Ten minutes on a Thursday afternoon is easier to keep up than a daily task.
How does Smart Review Stand fit in?
Smart Review Stand makes the first ask easy enough that fewer reminders are needed. A customer taps or scans and sees a page with your logo and five stars. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it.
Because the customer starts the review while standing at your counter, there is less to forget. Each Smart Review Stand card has its own link, and the dashboard counts taps, ratings and reviews started per card. Smart Review Stand does not send reminder messages for you. Prices are on the pricing page.
What is the short version?
- Most customers who agree and do not post have simply forgotten.
- Send one reminder, three to seven days after the first ask.
- Keep it to two or three sentences with the link in the message.
- Say plainly that the review is optional, and ask for an honest one.
- Never attach a reward, and never remind only the happy customers.
- Check for a recent review before you send.
- After one reminder, stop.