Review Rules Marketing Agencies Must Follow
Agencies that manage reviews for clients must follow Google's review policies. Learn what is allowed, what is risky, and what to put in the contract.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 8 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
A marketing agency that manages reviews for clients must follow the same rules as the business: reviews must come from real customers, must not be paid for or rewarded, must not be written by staff or the agency, and should not be requested only from happy customers. The agency's job is to make honest asking easier, to reply well, and to keep the client's profile accurate. This guide covers what is allowed, what is risky, and what both sides should put in writing, from the point of view of agencies and of the owners who hire them.
Why do agencies need their own rules?
Because the risk lands on the client. A profile that is penalized for fake reviews belongs to the business, not the agency, and the business loses the reviews it earned honestly along with the ones that broke the rules.
- Agencies work at scale, so a bad habit is repeated across many clients.
- Clients may not read the policy, and may assume the agency knows it.
- Pressure to show results can push people toward shortcuts.
Our guide on what counts as a fake Google review lists the common breaches.
What does Google's policy say?
Google's policy on prohibited and restricted content sets out the rules for contributed content, including fake engagement and conflicts of interest. In short, content should reflect real experience and should not be posted to manipulate ratings.
We are summarizing. Read the current page, and re-read it from time to time, since policies change.
What is clearly not allowed?
The following are breaches whoever does them.
- Writing reviews on behalf of a client or customer.
- Posting reviews from staff or the agency's own accounts.
- Buying or selling reviews. See buying Google reviews.
- Offering rewards, discounts or entries for a review. See incentives for Google reviews.
- Asking only happy customers. See what is review gating.
- Reviewing a competitor to harm them. See reviewing competitors.
Putting any of these in a package and calling it something else does not change what it is.
What can an agency legitimately do?
A lot. The honest work is the part that actually builds a record.
- Set up the profile correctly and keep details accurate.
- Create a review link and QR code, and place them well. See where to put review cards.
- Write a script for staff to ask in person. See how to ask for reviews in person.
- Send review requests to every real customer, by email or message, with consent.
- Draft replies for the client to approve.
- Report real policy violations and keep a record.
The agency's value is consistency and follow-through, not tricks.
How should agencies handle replies?
With care, because a reply is public and speaks for the client.
- Agree a tone and a set of examples with the client.
- Do not reveal customer details in a public reply.
- Escalate hard cases such as safety, legal or staff complaints to the owner.
- Keep replies honest. Do not claim a fix that did not happen.
Our guide on responding to Google reviews and on review reply mistakes give examples.
How should access be arranged?
Ownership stays with the client. The agency gets manager access, so it can be removed cleanly when the contract ends.
- Never ask for the owner login or to be the only owner.
- Use named accounts, not a shared mailbox.
- Record who has access and remove it on the end date.
Our guide on adding a manager to a Business Profile covers the steps.
What should the contract say?
A few plain lines about the rules, in writing. A contract that spells them out protects both sides.
- No fake, paid or rewarded reviews, and no gating.
- Reviews come from real customers, and requests go to all of them.
- The client owns the profile and the data.
- Access ends on the contract end date, and the agency confirms removal.
- No guarantee of a rating or a ranking. Google's help page on local ranking says you cannot pay to improve your place.
We are not lawyers, so have the final text checked.
What should an owner ask an agency?
A few direct questions reveal a lot.
- How do you get reviews, step by step?
- Do you ever pay for, write or post reviews?
- Who will own the profile and the review link?
- What will you report each month, and from where?
- What happens if a review is removed?
A good agency answers plainly. An evasive answer is a warning sign.
How do you report on reviews honestly?
With numbers that can be checked. Report what the client can verify on their own profile.
- New reviews and the average rating, month by month.
- Reply time, and the share of reviews with replies.
- Review requests sent and reviews started, where measured.
- Notes on what customers said, which is often the most useful part.
Our guide on how to track review card taps explains how to measure the in-person side.
What if a client asks for something against the rules?
It will happen. A client under pressure may ask for a quick boost or a rival knocked down. How the agency answers sets the tone for the relationship.
- Say no plainly, and give the reason in one sentence: the risk lands on the client's profile.
- Offer the honest alternative, such as a plan to ask every customer after each job.
- Put it in writing, so there is a record that the agency advised against it.
- Be ready to walk away if the client insists. An agency that agrees to fake reviews has made itself part of the problem.
Most clients accept this when it is explained well. Few understand that a penalized profile can lose honest reviews along with the bad ones.
How do you handle a client's past mistakes?
Many agencies inherit a profile that already has questionable reviews, bought long ago or posted by staff. Pretending they are not there does not help.
- Audit what exists. Look for reviews from staff, relatives or unfamiliar accounts, and note what you find.
- Stop the practice, and make sure nobody is still posting.
- Report reviews that clearly break the policy, through Google's tools. Our guide on how to report a Google review explains how.
- Build honest reviews steadily, so the questionable ones become a small share of the total.
Tell the client what you found, in plain words, and what you plan to do about it.
How do you keep the work sustainable?
Review work is a habit, not a campaign. Agencies that treat it as a monthly routine get better results with less drama.
- Agree a simple cadence: asking after each job, replying within a day or two, reporting monthly.
- Give the client's staff a short script and a card or sign, so asking does not depend on the agency being present.
- Review what works every quarter, using the counts and the wording customers use.
- Keep the client's own voice in replies, so the profile does not sound like a template.
An agency that makes the client better at asking, rather than doing it for them, is the one that keeps the contract.
How does Smart Review Stand fit in?
It gives an agency a simple, rule-friendly tool. A customer taps or scans and sees a page with your logo and five stars. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it.
Each Smart Review Stand card has its own link, and the dashboard counts taps, ratings and reviews started per card, which makes monthly reporting easier. Smart Review Stand is $25 per month for one location, and a card is $15 once, so $40 in total to start with one card. The annual plan is $210 a year, which is 30% less than paying monthly, and includes 2 NFC cards. Details are on the pricing page.
What is the short version?
- Reviews must come from real customers, and never be written for them.
- No payments, rewards or gating, whatever the package is called.
- Agencies may set up, request, reply and report honestly.
- Ownership stays with the client, and the agency gets manager access.
- Put the rules, the access dates and the exit terms in the contract.
- Never promise a rating or a ranking.