Should You Ask for a Review After a Complaint?
You can ask a customer for a review after fixing a complaint, but only if you ask everyone and offer nothing. See what Google allows and what to say.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 9 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
You can ask a customer for a review after a complaint, but only when the complaint is resolved and you ask in the same way you ask everyone else. A complaint is not a reason to skip someone, and it is not a reason to single them out. Google's rules are clear on the two things that go wrong here: rewards, and choosing which customers you invite. This guide covers how the rules apply, how to tell when the time is right, what to say, and when to say nothing.
For the wider picture of collecting reviews, start with our practical guide to getting more Google reviews. This post covers only the case where the customer was unhappy first.
What do Google's rules say about asking after a complaint?
They do not mention complaints by name, so we are applying general rules rather than quoting a specific one. Two parts of Google's prohibited and restricted content policy matter.
- No selective asking. The policy says merchants may not discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively ask only happy customers for reviews.
- No incentives. Google does not allow reviews posted because a business offered something of value, such as a discount, payment, or free goods or services. The policy says this includes reviews posted in exchange for changing or removing a negative one.
The same policy says a merchant may ask customers for genuine reviews, as long as it offers no incentive and does not try to influence the rating or what the review says.
Put together, the position is this. If your normal practice is to ask every customer, a customer who complained and was then helped belongs in that group like anyone else. If you skip every customer who complained, you are quietly choosing your reviewers. Our guide to Google's review policy goes through the rules in full.
Is it selective to skip customers who complained?
It can be. Imagine a shop that sends a review request to every customer by email, then removes anyone who contacted support. Over time its reviews would drift toward the satisfied, and that is the pattern the policy is aimed at.
The reverse also needs care. If you send a special, warmer request only to customers whose complaints you fixed, you are picking people by how they felt. The honest approach is one process for everyone:
- Same moment. The request goes out when the visit or job ends, for all customers.
- Same wording. No version of the message that is tuned to produce a better rating.
- Same link. Everyone reaches the same review form.
A customer with an open complaint is the one exception, and it is about timing, not selection. We cover that next.
When is it too soon to ask?
While the problem is still open. A request that arrives alongside an unresolved issue reads as an attempt to settle the matter with a good review, and it usually makes things worse.
Before you ask, check that:
- The customer has been heard. Someone has replied and listened.
- The problem is fixed or answered. A refund, a redo, an explanation, whatever the case needs.
- The customer has confirmed they are satisfied. Ask plainly whether there is anything else to do.
- Some time has passed. A day or two lets the fix settle.
If any of these is missing, wait, and if the complaint is not resolved, do not send the request at all. Our guide on the best time to ask for a Google review explains why timing matters for everyone.
Why can a complaint turn into a good review?
Because many people judge a business by how it behaves when something goes wrong. A customer who got a fast, honest fix may have a better opinion of you than one who never had a problem.
Google's own help page on tips for getting more reviews says that negative reviews are not necessarily a sign of poor business, and that a mix of positive and negative reviews often seems more trustworthy. You do not need a spotless page. You need an honest one.
That is the real case for asking after a complaint. It is not a trick to bury the complaint. It is a chance for the customer to describe the whole story, including how you handled it, in their own words.
What should you say?
Keep it short, make it optional, and offer nothing. The message should sound the same as the one you send anyone else, with a line of thanks for giving you the chance to fix things.
Here are three versions.
By email, after a fix.
"Hi Marcus, thank you for letting us put this right. If you would like to share how your visit went, here is a link to our Google page. It is entirely up to you."
In person, as a customer leaves.
"Thanks for your patience today. If you ever want to tell other people how it went, you can tap your phone on this card. No pressure at all."
When the customer is still annoyed.
Say nothing about reviews. Thank them, apologize if it is owed, and leave it there.
Notice what these leave out. None asks for a particular number of stars, none suggests wording, and none ties anything to the answer. Our guide on asking for reviews by text message has more on keeping a request plain.
What must you never do?
Anything that trades, pressures or scripts. These are the usual mistakes.
- Linking a refund to a review. "We will refund you once you post a review" offers something of value for a review.
- Offering a voucher. A discount or free item in return for a review is an incentive, even a small one.
- Asking for five stars. The policy says not to try to influence the rating or the content.
- Writing the review for them. The review has to be the customer's own account.
- Asking again and again. One request is the limit. A second reads as pressure.
- Asking only if the fix went well. That is selecting by outcome.
Our guide on incentives for Google reviews explains where the line sits on rewards.
What if the customer has already left a bad review?
Then the review request is not the point. Reply in public, fix the problem, and let the customer decide what to do next.
Google's page on managing customer reviews says replying shows customers that you value their feedback, and that the reviewer is notified when you reply. It also says reviewers can change their reviews after reading a reply, and that the review date updates when they do.
That is useful to know. A good reply gives the reviewer a reason to look again, and you do not need to ask them to change anything. If you do mention it, do it once, politely, with nothing offered. We cover this case in detail in can you ask a customer to change their review, and the wording of the reply itself in how to respond to negative Google reviews.
What if the complaint was private and never public?
Then the customer has not posted anything, and there is nothing to change. Treat them the way you treat everyone else once the problem is solved.
Many businesses give unhappy customers a private way to reach them, such as a phone number or a feedback form. That is good practice, because it lets you fix a problem while the customer is still willing to talk. The rule to keep in mind is that a private route must never replace the public one. Do not discourage a customer from posting a review, and do not suggest that they should not.
Smart Review Stand works along these lines. A customer taps or scans and sees your rating page. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it. The private note is a way to reach you quickly. It does not stop anyone from posting on Google. We cover the rules on this in private feedback forms and Google's rules, and the plans are on the pricing page.
Should you ever skip the request?
Sometimes, yes, and that is fine as long as the reason is not the rating.
Reasons to leave a customer out of a request:
- The complaint is unresolved. Wait until it is.
- The customer asked to be left alone. Respect that.
- The matter is sensitive. A complaint about a death, an injury or a privacy issue is not a moment for a review request.
- A legal or insurance process is under way. Ask a professional before contacting the customer.
Reasons that are not acceptable: the customer might give a low rating, or the customer was rude. Leaving out people because you expect a poor review is the selection the policy forbids.
How should staff handle the moment?
With a clear, short rule. Staff are most likely to get this wrong under pressure, so give them something simple.
- Fix first, ask never in the same conversation. Do not mix the two.
- Use the normal request. The same words as for every customer.
- If in doubt, say thank you and stop. A missing request costs you little.
- Never promise anything for a review. Not a discount, a coffee or a refund.
Google's policy also says staff should not be pressured to leave reviews or be set review quotas, so keep the rule about the request you make to customers, not about targets. Our guide on how to train staff to ask for reviews covers the routine in more detail.
What is the short version?
- Asking after a complaint is allowed when you ask everyone, offer nothing and do not shape the answer.
- Resolve the complaint first, and confirm the customer is satisfied.
- Use the same wording you use for every customer, with one line of thanks.
- Never link a refund, a gift or a discount to a review.
- Do not ask for a star rating or supply the text.
- Make one request at most. If the answer is no, accept it.
- Skip the request only for reasons that have nothing to do with the rating.