Skip to main content
Smart Review Stand

Can You Ask a Customer to Change Their Review?

You can ask a customer to update a review after you fix the problem, but not pay or pressure them. See what Google's rules allow and what to say.

By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 9 min read

You can tell a customer that they are welcome to update their review once you have fixed the problem, but you cannot pay them, bargain with them or pressure them to do it. The review belongs to the customer, and so does the decision. This guide covers what Google's rules say, where the line sits between a fair mention and pressure, what to fix first, sample wording, and what to do when the answer is no.

What do Google's rules say?

They do not address this exact question, so we will not pretend they do. Two rules in Google's prohibited and restricted content policy set the limits.

  • No incentives. The policy does not allow rewards in exchange for reviews. We read that as covering a reward for changing or removing one, since the result is the same: a rating that was paid for.
  • No discouraging negative reviews. The policy says a business may not discourage or prohibit negative reviews, and may not selectively solicit positive ones.

What the pages we cite do not contain is a sentence saying "a business may ask a customer to update a review". Our reading is that a single, polite, no-strings mention after a genuine fix stays inside both rules. That is our interpretation, not a quotation.

Our guide on the Google review policy explains the rules in full.

Who controls a review once it is posted?

The reviewer. They can edit the rating, rewrite the text or delete the review whenever they like.

A business has three options and no more:

  • Reply in public. Google's page on replying to reviews explains how.
  • Report a review that breaks policy. Google's page on reporting inappropriate reviews says only reviews that violate its policies are eligible for removal, and that a business should not report a review merely because it disagrees with it.
  • Talk to the customer.

There is no setting that lets a business edit, hide or delete a customer's review. Our guide on whether a business can delete a Google review covers that in detail.

Where is the line between asking and pressuring?

At the point where the customer would feel that something depends on their answer. A mention leaves them free. Pressure does not.

Inside the line:

  • Fixing the problem first, with no condition.
  • Mentioning once that they can update the review if they wish.
  • Thanking them whether or not they do.
  • Replying in public with what you did.

Outside the line:

  • "We will refund you once the review is removed."
  • "Change it to five stars and the next visit is free."
  • Asking a second and third time.
  • Having several members of staff contact the customer.
  • Mentioning lawyers to frighten a customer into deleting an honest review.
  • A contract or terms that forbid negative reviews.
  • Writing the new review for them.

The test is simple. Would you be comfortable if the customer posted your message, word for word, as an update to the review? If not, do not send it.

What must happen before you mention the review?

The problem has to be fixed. Asking for a better rating before earning one is asking the customer to say something untrue.

  1. Reply in public first. Short and calm. Acknowledge the problem and say you will be in touch.
  2. Contact the customer privately. Phone is best. Listen before you explain.
  3. Put it right. Refund, redo, replace or apologize, as the case needs.
  4. Confirm they are satisfied. Ask plainly: "Is there anything else we should do?"
  5. Wait. A day or two. Let the fix settle.
  6. Then, and only once, mention the review. Or do not mention it at all. Many customers update a review unprompted when a business handles a complaint well.

Step six is optional. A business that never asks will still benefit from steps one to four, because the public reply shows everyone how the complaint was handled.

Our guide on how to respond to negative Google reviews covers the public reply, and our guide on how to apologize in a review reply covers the wording.

What can you say?

Something short that leaves the choice with the customer. Here are four versions.

After a fix, by phone.

"I am glad we got that sorted, Dana. One last thing, and it is entirely up to you: if you feel your review no longer reflects where things ended up, you are welcome to update it. If you would prefer to leave it as it is, that is fine too."

After a fix, by email.

"Hi Marcus, thank you for giving us the chance to put this right. The refund went through this morning. If you ever feel like updating your review to reflect how things turned out, we would appreciate it. There is no obligation either way."

When the customer raises it first.

"That is kind of you, Elena. You can edit the review from your own Google account whenever suits you. Please write whatever you honestly think."

When you decide not to ask.

"Thank you for letting us fix this, Ben. We are sorry it happened, and we hope to see you again."

Notice what all four leave out. None names a star rating. None suggests wording. None ties anything to the outcome.

What should you never say?

Anything that trades, threatens or scripts. These examples are common, and each one crosses the line.

  • "As soon as the review comes down, I will process the refund." A refund held hostage.
  • "Would you change it to five stars? I will add a voucher." An incentive.
  • "This review is damaging my family's income." Guilt as pressure.
  • "Our solicitor has advised that your review is defamatory." Unless a lawyer has in fact advised you and the review is false, this is a threat.
  • "Here is some text you could paste in." The review must be the customer's own words.
  • "Could you delete it and post a new one?" Leave the mechanics to them.

If a review contains false statements of fact that are causing real harm, that is a matter for legal advice, not for a strongly worded message. We are not lawyers.

Is a refund or a remedy an incentive?

Not when it is owed and unconditional. Putting things right is ordinary customer service.

The difference is the condition:

  • Remedy. "We have refunded your order." Given because the service failed.
  • Incentive. "We will refund your order if you change the review." Given to buy a rating.

Keep the two apart in time and in writing. Complete the remedy. Send the confirmation. Let a day pass. If you mention the review at all, do it in a separate message that does not refer to the money.

Thanking a customer in words after they update a review is not an incentive. A reward promised in advance is. Our guide on incentives for Google reviews explains the difference.

What if the review is unfair or untrue?

Then the question changes. You are not asking a satisfied customer to update an honest review. You are dealing with content that may break policy.

Do not contact a reviewer repeatedly to argue the facts. That turns a one-star review into a one-star review with an update about harassment.

What if the customer says no, or says nothing?

Accept it. One mention is the limit.

What to do instead:

  • Make sure your public reply is good. It should say what went wrong and what you did. Our guide on how to edit a Google review reply shows how to update a reply after a fix.
  • Keep asking every customer for reviews. A steady flow of recent, honest reviews puts one bad review in proportion.
  • Fix the cause. If the review was right, the same complaint will come again until the cause is gone.

Google's tips for getting more reviews describe how to ask customers for reviews in the normal course of business. Our free star rating calculator shows how many new reviews it takes to move an average.

A single low review among many good ones does less harm than owners fear. A page of perfect scores can look less believable than a page with a few complaints and thoughtful replies.

Can you ask a happy customer to add detail to a review?

Yes, on the same terms: once, politely, with nothing offered and no wording supplied. A customer who left five stars and no text may be glad of a nudge.

"Thank you so much for the review, Sarah. If you ever have a minute to add a line about what you had done, it helps other customers know what to expect. Only if you feel like it."

Do not ask a customer to change a four to a five. That is asking for a rating, not for an honest account.

How does Smart Review Stand fit in?

Smart Review Stand gives an unhappy customer a way to reach you at the moment of the visit. A customer taps or scans and sees a page with your logo and five stars. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it.

That private note is a chance to fix a problem while the customer is still willing to talk. It does not stop anyone from posting on Google, and it is not meant to. Prices are on the pricing page.

What is the short version?

  • The review belongs to the customer. Only they can change or delete it.
  • Fix the problem first, with no conditions attached.
  • You may mention once that they are free to update the review.
  • Never tie a refund, a gift or a discount to a change.
  • Never name a star rating or supply the wording.
  • If the answer is no, accept it and rely on a good public reply.
  • Report a review only when it breaks Google's policies.

Common questions

You can let a customer know, once and politely, that they are free to update a review after you have put the problem right. You cannot offer anything in return, make a refund depend on it, or pressure them.

No. Google's content policy does not allow incentives, and it says a business may not discourage or prohibit negative reviews. Give the refund because it is owed, and leave the review to the customer.

Yes. A reviewer can change the rating and the text of their own review, or delete it. A business cannot edit or delete a customer's review.

Accept it and move on. Post a calm public reply that says what you did to fix the problem. Future customers will read both the review and the reply.

Put a card on the counter this week.

Setup takes about ten minutes, and you can test your rating page before any card arrives.

14 days free. No payment details needed. No contract, cancel any time.

Start your 14-day free trial

We store your theme and sign-in on this device. With your permission we also load Google reCAPTCHA and anonymous usage statistics. Cookie policy.