A Google Review Rules Checklist for Owners
A plain checklist of Google's review rules for business owners: what you may ask, what is banned, and what to check before you send a request.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 7 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
Before you ask for a Google review, check six things: you are asking real customers, you are asking all of them, you are offering nothing in return, you are not writing or editing reviews, you are not asking staff or family, and you are not asking anyone to remove or change a review. Google's help pages encourage businesses to ask customers for reviews, and the rules concern how. This checklist puts them in one place, each with a short reason and a link to a longer guide.
What is the quick checklist?
Print this and keep it near whoever sends review requests.
- Every request goes to a real customer who used the business.
- Requests go to all customers, not only the happy ones.
- No reward, discount, gift or entry for a review.
- No staff, owners, relatives or friends posting reviews.
- No reviews written, bought or edited on someone's behalf.
- No requests to remove or change a review, or pressure about its content.
- No reviews of competitors posted to harm them.
- Nothing in the request promises a particular rating.
The sections below explain each line.
Are you asking real customers?
Reviews should reflect a real experience. Ask people who have actually been to your business or used your service.
- Ask after a real visit, a job done or a purchase made.
- Do not ask people who have not used you, such as contacts from a bought list.
- Do not create accounts or use other people's accounts.
Our guide on what counts as a fake Google review lists the common types.
Are you asking everyone?
Selecting who may review is not allowed. This is called review gating, and it includes sending unhappy customers to a private form and only happy ones to Google.
- Make the Google link available to everyone.
- A private note option is fine if it does not replace the Google link.
- Do not hide the link from people who gave a low rating.
Our guides on what is review gating and on private feedback forms and Google rules explain the difference.
Are you offering anything in return?
Do not. Rewards for reviews are against Google's policy, even small ones and even when they are offered for any review, good or bad.
- No money, discounts, free items or entries into a draw.
- No special treatment for people who post.
- Thank people in words, after the review, with no strings.
Our guides on incentives for Google reviews and on review contests and giveaways go into more detail.
Are staff and family posting?
They should not. A review from someone with a stake in the business is a conflict of interest.
- Owners and employees should not review their own business.
- Friends and relatives can post only if they were real customers, and even then it can look biased, so we would ask them not to.
- Do not ask staff to leave reviews to get the count up.
Our guides on whether employees can leave Google reviews and on friends and family reviews give more.
Are you writing, buying or editing reviews?
Never. Reviews must be the customer's own words.
- Do not write reviews for customers, even with their permission.
- Do not buy reviews from a service. See buying Google reviews.
- Do not hand customers a script to post word for word.
- Do not ask a customer to change a review to be kinder. See can you ask a customer to change a review.
Are you reviewing competitors?
Do not. A review from a rival is a conflict of interest and likely to be treated as manipulation. Our guide on reviewing competitors explains why.
What can you safely do?
A lot, and it is the part that works best.
- Ask in person, at the moment a customer says thank you. See how to ask for reviews in person.
- Make it easy, with a direct link and a QR code. Our free review link generator builds one.
- Follow up once, politely. See how to follow up a review request.
- Reply to every review. See how to respond to Google reviews.
Google's help page on asking customers for reviews explains how to share your link.
What happens if you break the rules?
Reviews can be removed and, in serious cases, a profile can be penalized. We will not say exactly what Google does in each case, since it varies. Our guide on what reviews Google removes covers what is commonly taken down, and the risk is rarely worth the shortcut.
What are the common gray areas?
Most owners are not trying to cheat. They get into trouble through small habits that seem harmless. These are the ones we see most often.
- "Leave us five stars" in a request. Asking for a review is fine. Asking for a particular rating is not, and it reads as pressure.
- A thank-you gift handed over before a customer has said anything. If it is linked to a review in the customer's mind, it can count as an incentive.
- A tablet at the counter that only staff can use for a customer. Reviews should be written by the customer, on their own account.
- Asking regulars only. Regulars are real customers, but choosing only the ones you know will be positive leans toward selection.
- Replying with an offer such as "come back for a free coffee" to a bad review. It can look like buying back goodwill, so keep replies to the facts.
If something falls in this list, reword it or drop it. The cost of a plainer request is small.
How do you use Google's own pages?
Google's policy on prohibited and restricted content is the page to read for the full wording, including fake engagement and conflicts of interest. This checklist is our summary and is not a replacement for it.
- Read the page itself at least once, so you know the exact terms.
- Note the date you last checked it, in your team's notes.
- Check again when you change how you ask, for example when you add a new channel such as email or a card.
We are not lawyers, and the rules differ in some places, so seek advice if your case is unusual.
How do you review your own process?
Once or twice a year, walk through what a customer actually experiences, from the first request to the review itself.
- Write down every step, including who asks, with what words and where the link comes from.
- Tick each line of the quick checklist against it.
- Ask staff what they really say, not what the script says. The two often differ.
- Fix the gaps and tell everyone what changed.
A process that is simple and written down is far easier to keep honest than one that lives in people's heads.
How do you keep a team on the rules?
By making them simple and visible. People break rules they never heard.
- Put the checklist where requests are sent.
- Train new staff on day one. See how to train staff to ask for reviews.
- Review your wording once or twice a year against Google's current pages.
- Keep a note of what you ask and how, so you can show it if questioned.
How does Smart Review Stand fit in?
It is built around the checklist. A customer taps or scans and sees a page with your logo and five stars. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it.
Each Smart Review Stand card has its own link, and the dashboard counts taps, ratings and reviews started per card. Smart Review Stand is $25 per month for one location, and a card is $15 once, so $40 in total to start with one card. The annual plan is $210 a year, which is 30% less than paying monthly, and includes 2 NFC cards. Details are on the pricing page.
What is the short version?
- Ask real customers, and ask all of them.
- Offer nothing in return, and never gate.
- No staff, family or competitor reviews.
- Never write, buy or edit a review.
- Do not pressure anyone to change or remove one.
- Re-read Google's pages once or twice a year.