Do Google Reviews Help Your Local Ranking?
Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking. What that means, what else counts, and what a local business should do about it.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 7 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
Yes. Google says so directly: on its help page about local results it states that more reviews and positive ratings can help a business's local ranking. Reviews are not the only thing that counts, and Google gives no figure for how much they count, but they are one of the few ranking inputs a local business can influence every working day. This guide sets out what Google has said, what it has not said, and what to do with that.
What does Google say decides local ranking?
Google's page on improving your local ranking names three factors.
Relevance is how well a Business Profile matches what the person searched for. A complete profile with the right category helps Google understand what you do.
Distance is how far each business is from the person searching, or from the place they named in the search.
Prominence is how well known a business is. Google says this draws on information from across the web, and it names two things in particular: how many websites link to the business, and how many reviews it has.
Google combines the three. A business that is further away can still appear above a nearer one if it is a much better match or is much more prominent. That is the opening reviews give you. You cannot move your premises, but you can become better known.
Where do reviews fit in?
Reviews sit inside prominence. Google's page says that more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking, and it lists replying to reviews among the steps it recommends.
Read that sentence closely, because it contains two separate things. One is the number of reviews. The other is the rating. A profile with many reviews and a poor average is not what Google describes, and neither is a perfect average built on three reviews. Both parts matter.
Notice also the word "can." Google does not promise a result. Reviews improve your chances in a system that also weighs relevance and distance, and nobody outside Google knows the weights.
What has Google not said?
A great deal is written about local ranking that Google has never confirmed. It is worth knowing where the line is.
Google has not published a number of reviews that guarantees a position. Any article that says "you need fifty reviews to reach the top three" is guessing.
Google has not said that words inside a review act as ranking keywords. A review that mentions "emergency plumber" may help a reader. Whether it changes ranking is not something Google has stated. In any case its policy on prohibited and restricted content says a business must not ask customers to include specific content, so you cannot ask for keywords.
Google has not said that a reply raises your position by a set amount. It recommends replying because it shows customers you are responsive.
What Google has said plainly is that you cannot buy your way up. The same help page states there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking.
Why do reviews matter even apart from ranking?
Ranking gets you seen. It does not get you chosen. In local results a searcher sees several businesses side by side, each with a star rating and a review count beside its name. That is often the only information on screen before they tap.
So reviews work twice. They can help you appear, and then they help the searcher pick you over the business listed next to you. A business in second place with a strong, recent set of reviews will often win the customer from a business in first place with few.
Recency is part of this. A reader who sees that the latest review is two years old wonders whether the business has changed hands or closed. A steady flow of new reviews answers that question before it is asked.
What should a local business do about it?
Google's page gives the list, and none of it is hidden.
Verify your profile. Only a verified business can manage its information and reply to reviews. If you have not done it yet, our Google Business Profile setup guide walks through it.
Complete and maintain your information. Address, phone number, hours, category and attributes all feed relevance. Wrong hours cost you more than any ranking factor, because a customer who arrives at a closed door writes the review you least want.
Ask for reviews, every day. This is the part that builds prominence. Google's page on getting more reviews says a business can encourage reviews by sharing a link or QR code. The full method is in how to get more Google reviews.
Reply to reviews. Thank people for the good ones and answer the bad ones calmly. Google notifies the reviewer when you reply.
Add photos. Google recommends photos and videos to show what you offer.
Of these five, asking for reviews is the one most businesses neglect, because it has to be done again every day and the other four are mostly done once.
How do you earn reviews steadily?
Steady is the word that matters. Fifty reviews in one week followed by none for a year looks odd to readers. A few each week looks like a business with customers.
A steady flow comes from a habit, and a habit needs a fixed place in the working day. Pick the moment the customer has what they came for, usually payment or handover, and attach the request to it. Say one sentence. Have the link in reach: a printed QR code, a tap card, or a link in the receipt email. Then measure it, so you know whether the habit is alive.
Measuring is where most efforts fade. Without a count, nobody notices that the team stopped asking three weeks ago. With Smart Review Stand, each card has its own link, and the dashboard counts taps, ratings and reviews started per card and per week. A flat line shows on the first Monday, not three months later. How it works shows the sequence from tap to review, and the star rating calculator shows how many new reviews it takes to move your average.
Which shortcuts should you avoid?
Because reviews can help ranking, there is a market in faking them. Every shortcut on offer breaks Google's policy, and the penalties fall on the business.
Buying reviews. Reviews must reflect a genuine experience. Purchased reviews are fake engagement.
Rewards. Google's policy forbids offering payment, discounts, free goods or free services in exchange for a review. That covers a prize draw and a free dessert as much as cash.
Asking only happy customers. The policy forbids selectively soliciting positive reviews and discouraging negative ones.
Reviews from staff, family or yourself. The policy treats these as a conflict of interest.
Google removes reviews that break these rules and can restrict a profile that keeps breaking them. A profile that loses a block of reviews overnight is worse off than one that never had them. Our guide to Google's review policy covers each rule.
How long does it take to see a change?
Google gives no timetable, and anyone who promises one is guessing. What you can observe yourself is simpler. Your review count rises from the first week you start asking. Your average rating moves slowly if you already have many reviews and quickly if you have few. Your position in local results depends on those and on everything your competitors are doing at the same time.
Treat reviews as a routine and not as a campaign. Ranking is a result you do not control. The request at the counter is the part you do, and it is worth doing whether or not the position changes this month, because the customer comparing two listings reads the reviews either way.