What to Check Before You Buy Review Cards
Buying Google review cards? Check who controls the link, whether the card has a QR code, what the customer sees, and what it costs after the first year.
By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 9 min read
Dana, a week ago
Example“Quick to tap, and they fixed my order without any fuss.”
Reply from the owner
Thank you, Dana. We are glad it worked. See you next week.
Before you buy Google review cards, check five things: where the card's link points and who controls it, whether the card has a QR code as well as NFC, what a customer sees after tapping, whether you get any numbers back, and what it costs over a full year. Most review cards look the same in a product photo. The differences are in the link and in what happens after the tap. This guide covers each check, the questions to ask a seller, and the claims that should make you walk away.
What is a review card, in plain terms?
A review card is a plastic card, stand or sticker that sends a customer's phone to a web page.
Most have two ways in. An NFC chip inside the card holds a web link, and a phone held close to it offers to open that link. A printed QR code holds the same link for the camera. Android's developer guide to NFC basics describes how a phone reads this kind of data from a tag.
The card itself does very little. It is a shortcut. What matters is the page at the other end. Our guide to NFC review cards explained covers the basics in more depth.
Where does the link point, and who controls it?
This is the first question, and the one most buyers skip.
There are three common setups.
- Straight to Google. The card holds your Google review link. Simple, and nothing sits between the customer and the review form. You get no numbers, and if the link ever needs to change, the card must be rewritten or replaced.
- Through the seller's short link. The card holds a link on the seller's domain, which forwards to your review form. The seller can change the destination without touching the card. If the seller closes or you stop paying, the card may stop working.
- To a page the seller hosts. The card opens a page with your branding, which then leads to Google. You get a view of what customers do. The same dependence applies.
None of these is wrong. You need to know which one you are buying.
Ask the seller:
- What exact web address is written to the card?
- Can I change where it goes, and how?
- What happens to the card if I cancel?
Google's help page on review links and QR codes explains how to get your own review link from your Business Profile. Have it ready before you order, and check that the card ends up there. Our free Google review link generator builds the link from your Place ID.
Does the card have a QR code as well?
It should.
Not every phone can tap. iPhone XS and newer read a card without setup, and most Android phones made since 2015 do too when NFC is switched on. Some phones have NFC switched off, some budget models have no reader, and some customers have never tapped anything but a payment terminal.
A QR code covers all of them. Any phone with a camera can scan it.
Check that the QR code:
- Is printed large enough to scan from a comfortable distance.
- Has clear space around it and good contrast.
- Leads to the same place as the tap.
Our guide on which phones can tap an NFC review card lists what works and what does not.
What does the customer see after tapping?
Ask for a live demo link and try it on your own phone before you pay.
Look for these things.
- No app. The page should open in the browser. A card that asks customers to install an app will lose most of them.
- Speed. The page should load in a second or two on mobile data.
- Your business, clearly. The customer should be sure they are reviewing the right place.
- A short path. Count the taps between the card and the Google review form. Fewer is better.
- No sign-up wall. The customer should not have to give an email address or phone number to continue.
Then check what the page does with a low rating. This matters more than anything else on the list.
Does the product stay inside Google's rules?
Some review products promise to "stop bad reviews" or "send only happy customers to Google". Avoid them.
Google's prohibited and restricted content policy says a business may not discourage or prohibit negative reviews, and may not selectively solicit positive reviews from customers. A page that shows the Google link only to customers who pick a high rating does exactly that. The practice is called review gating, and our guide on what review gating is explains it.
The risk sits with you, not the seller. It is your Business Profile and your reviews.
A page can offer an unhappy customer a private way to tell you first. That is useful. The test is whether the customer can still reach Google.
Check on the demo:
- Pick a low rating.
- Look for a link to the Google review form on the next screen.
- If there is none, do not buy.
Also walk away from any seller that offers to supply reviews, promises a star rating, or suggests rewarding customers for reviewing. Google says incentives in exchange for reviews are strictly prohibited.
Do you get any numbers back?
A plain card tells you nothing. You hand it out and hope.
Numbers are not essential, but they answer questions you will have within a month.
- Is anyone tapping the card at all?
- Which card gets used: the one at the till or the one on the table?
- Which staff member's card gets the most taps?
- How many taps turn into a review being started?
If the seller offers a dashboard, ask what it counts. A seller can count taps and what happens on its own page. No seller can see inside Google's form, so be wary of a claim to know exactly how many reviews each card produced.
Ask whether each card has its own link. If every card shares one link, the numbers cannot tell cards apart.
What will it cost over a full year?
Add up everything, not only the card.
- The card. One-time, or included in a plan.
- A subscription. Monthly or yearly, if the card depends on a hosted page.
- Extra cards. You will probably want more than one.
- Replacements. Cards get lost, bent and spilled on.
- Changes. A fee to update the link or the artwork.
- Shipping and setup.
A card with no subscription is cheaper in year one and gives you no page and no numbers. A subscription costs more and can be changed without reprinting. Work out which you need before comparing prices.
Ask about cancelling. Find out whether there is a minimum term, whether you can get a refund, and whether the card keeps working afterwards.
Is the card itself well made?
A few physical checks.
- Material. A card on a counter gets wiped, knocked and splashed. Thin card stock will not last.
- Print quality. Blurry logos and faint QR codes look careless.
- Size and format. A stand for a counter, a flat card to hand over, a sticker for a window. Buy for where it will sit.
- Metal surfaces. NFC signals are weakened by metal. A sticker meant for a steel counter needs to be designed for it.
- Wording. The card should say what to do: "Tap or scan to leave a review".
Can the card be changed later?
Businesses move, merge listings and rebrand.
Ask whether the chip is locked. A locked card can never be rewritten, which protects it from tampering and also means it is tied to one link forever. An unlocked card can be rewritten with a phone, by you or by anyone else who picks it up.
A card that points to a link the seller can redirect avoids both problems, as long as the seller stays in business.
If you already own cards, you may not need new ones. Our guide on whether you can rewrite an NFC review card explains when that is possible.
What questions should you ask a seller?
Copy this list into an email.
- What exact link is written to the card?
- Can I change the destination, and what does that cost?
- Does every card have a QR code as well as NFC?
- Can I try a live demo on my own phone?
- What does a customer see after choosing a low rating?
- Does the customer need an app or an account with you?
- What do you count, and does each card have its own link?
- What is the full cost for one year with the number of cards I need?
- What happens to my cards if I cancel?
- Is the chip locked?
A seller who answers all ten plainly is worth considering. A seller who avoids number 5 is not.
How does Smart Review Stand answer these?
Here are our own answers, so you can hold us to the same list.
A customer taps or scans and sees a page with your logo and five stars. A rating of 4 or 5 stars opens your Google review form. A rating of 1 to 3 stars offers a short private note to you first, with a smaller link to Google below it.
No app is needed. Every card also has a QR code. Each Smart Review Stand card has its own link, and the dashboard counts taps, ratings and reviews started per card. Smart Review Stand can also rewrite an NFC card you already have, if it is not locked.
Smart Review Stand is $25 per month for one location, and a card is $15 once, so $40 in total to start with one card. The annual plan is $210 a year, which is 30% less than paying monthly, and includes 2 NFC cards. Details are on the pricing page, and the features page lists what is included.
What is the short version?
- Find out exactly what link is on the card and who can change it.
- Buy cards with a QR code as well as NFC, so every phone can use them.
- Try a live demo on your own phone before paying.
- Pick a low rating in the demo; if the Google link disappears, do not buy.
- Avoid any seller promising to block bad reviews, supply reviews or reward reviewers.
- Add up the cost for a full year, including extra cards and cancellation terms.
- Ask whether the chip is locked and what happens to the card if you cancel.