Skip to main content
Smart Review Stand

Paper vs NFC Review Cards: Which Gets More Reviews?

Paper review cards cost pennies but give you no data. NFC cards cost more and show who taps. Compare cost, speed and tracking to pick the right one.

By Alan James, Founder, Smart Review Stand · Published · 7 min read

NFC cards get more reviews started than paper cards in most settings, because a tap takes one movement and a printed QR code takes three. Paper wins on price: a printed card costs a few cents and an NFC card costs a few dollars. Paper loses on everything after the handout, since you cannot count who used it, change where it points, or tell whether it is working. This guide compares the two on cost, speed, tracking and durability so you can decide which belongs on your counter.

What is the difference between a paper card and an NFC card?

A paper review card is printed with a QR code, a short link, or both. The customer scans the code with the camera or types the link. Nothing electronic is inside.

An NFC review card has a small chip sealed inside plastic. The chip stores a web link. When a phone is held close, it reads the chip and offers the link. Most NFC cards also print a QR code on the face, so one card does both jobs. Our guide to how NFC review cards work explains the chip in detail.

In both cases the link opens in the phone's browser. The customer installs no app.

Which one is faster for the customer?

NFC, when the customer is standing in front of the card.

  • Tap: hold the phone near the card, then touch the link that appears.
  • Scan a paper code: unlock the phone, open the camera, frame the code, then touch the link.
  • Type a short link: open a browser, type the address correctly, load the page.

Every extra step loses some people. That matters most at the moment you want them to act, which is usually right after they pay. Our post on NFC vs QR codes for reviews covers the speed difference and which phones can tap.

Paper has one speed advantage: it can be handed over. A customer who is leaving can take the card home and scan it later. That helps with deliveries, tradespeople on a job and take-away orders.

How much do paper and NFC cards cost?

Paper is far cheaper per piece. Printing a batch of small cards or flyers costs very little, and you can print as many as you like.

For Smart Review Stand, the subscription is $25 a month, or $210 a year with 2 NFC cards included. Extra NFC cards are $15 each, paid once. You pay for the software behind the card, which is what makes tracking and link changes possible. Paper has no such cost because it has no such features.

Compare the cost against what a missed review is worth to you, not against the price of printing. A card that customers ignore is expensive at any price. Our guide on how many review cards one location needs helps you avoid buying more than you will use.

Can you track paper cards?

Not by itself. A printed code points to a link, and the link works the same whether ten people or none scanned it. Unless the link is a tracked one, you will see no difference in your own records.

An NFC card from a service like ours has a link of its own. The dashboard counts taps, ratings and reviews started for each card, so you can see which counter or staff member produces results. Our post on how to track review card taps shows what to look at.

Two limits apply to any tracking:

  • A tap or a scan is not a review. A customer can open the page and leave. The count shows interest, not posted reviews.
  • Your Google Business Profile is the only place that shows reviews actually posted.

With paper, you reprint. If you move premises, merge a listing or fix a wrong link, every card and flyer in circulation points to the old address until you replace it.

With a card whose link you control, you change the destination in one place and every card follows. Cards that write the Google address straight into the chip behave like paper in this respect, since the address is stored on the chip. Check which kind you are buying. Our guide on rewriting an NFC review card explains the options.

Which lasts longer?

A plastic NFC card survives a wallet, a counter and a wipe-down. Paper curls, tears and stains, and a card that looks tired makes the request look tired too.

Metal surfaces can weaken NFC reads, so test a card on the surface where it will sit. Paper has no such problem, because it relies on the camera, not a radio.

When does paper make more sense?

  • One-off events and mailings. You will not collect the cards again, so keep the cost low.
  • Receipts, packaging and delivery bags. The code travels with the order and the customer scans it later.
  • A backup beside the NFC card. Phones that cannot tap still need a way in.
  • A very tight budget at launch. A printed sign with a correct link is better than no ask at all.

When does an NFC card make more sense?

  • A counter, desk or table where customers pay. The tap is quick and visible.
  • Staff who ask in person. A card in the hand is a prompt to say the words.
  • Several staff or several counters. Per-card counts show who is asking.
  • A link you may need to change. One edit instead of a reprint.

For the physical form, see stand vs card vs sticker.

How do you set up each kind correctly?

For a paper card, get the link right before printing. Open it on a phone, confirm it lands on the form to write a review for your business, then print one test copy and scan it from the distance a customer would. Print a short line above the code so nobody has to guess what it does. Our guide on print size for a review QR code gives a safe minimum, and the post on how to make a Google review QR code walks through making one.

For an NFC card, tap it with an iPhone and an Android phone before it goes on the counter. Try it on the surface where it will sit. If a read fails, this checklist covers the usual causes, from a case that is too thick to NFC being switched off.

In both cases, write the same short line: "Tap or scan to leave us a review". Customers should not have to work out which to use.

What should you do?

Use both, with different jobs. Keep an NFC card at the place where customers pay, and give paper where the customer leaves with something in hand. Point both at the same Google review page, and write a short line on each, such as "Tap or scan to leave us a review".

Check the link first. Open it on your own phone and confirm it lands on the form to write a review for your business. Google describes how to get a review link or QR code in its help page on creating a review link or QR code.

Then ask in person. Whichever card you use, it only helps when someone puts it in front of the customer. Google's own tips to get more reviews also remind owners to follow its policies. Do not offer a reward for a review and do not ask only happy customers. If you want to see how a tap looks to a customer, try the demo or read the pricing page.

Common questions

For most counters, yes, because a tap is quicker than scanning a printed code and the card can report how often it is used. A paper card is cheaper and fine for a one-off handout, but it tells you nothing after it leaves your hand.

Yes. Many businesses keep an NFC card at the counter and give paper handouts with receipts or deliveries. Point both at the same Google review page and you lose nothing.

No. The chip is powered by the phone for the moment it is read, and the link opens in the phone's browser. The customer installs nothing.

No. Ink cannot be edited. If your review link changes, every printed card is out of date. A card with a link that you control can send customers to a new page without being replaced.

Put a card on the counter this week.

Setup takes about ten minutes, and you can test your rating page before any card arrives.

14 days free. No payment details needed. No contract, cancel any time.

Start your 14-day free trial

We store your theme and sign-in on this device. With your permission we also load Google reCAPTCHA and anonymous usage statistics. Cookie policy.